[persian54]

For those with a 3GS and have upgrade, what are you thoughts?

I'm personally very disappointed

over a basic 3.X, I would admit it's a great improvement (especially the multitasking)

but when compared to a customized 3.X (for example, the way I set up my own 3.1.2 jailbroken iPhone), I feel it falls short

Particularly the loss of SBSettings and Lockinfo for me

Having to actually unlock the phone to read email/delete junk/etc can get some getting used to... and not being able to turn bluetooth/wireless on/off on the fly will get annoying fast

I know the dev team has jailbroken it and are just about to finish it, but nonetheless... at this point I went back to 3.1.2.

How about you guys?

[ragingclue]

Did you expect iOS4 to be better than a jailbroken 3.X?

[tweak84]

i have a 3g and it made my phone seem really slow, i cant wait till my new one gets here.

[Feyd]

I put it on my 3g yesterday.

It is laggy as fuck and completely not worth it on a 3G... perhaps the 3Gs can actually run it fast enough, but not on an old 3g.

The email threading is cool, but laggy menus/laggy navigaion/just plain laggy performance is a FAIL imo.

[Kensta335]

Not gonna upgrade it. I love my jb3.1.2. I'm going to get the iphone 4 anyways.

[JasonCSU]

I just upgraded my 3G and haven't noticed much lag, but I haven't used it much yet.

[hl0m4n]

i upgraded to ios4 jailbroke and unlocked on a 3g and there is a slight noticable delay when opening anything... maybe the 3gs has no lag but on a 3g i do...

but i can't complain on the overall package of the ios4 so the small delay is no biggie.

[persian54]

Originally Posted by ragingclue

Did you expect iOS4 to be better than a jailbroken 3.X?

Guess I was being hopefully

Looked really cool on their website

now I'm sad.. until the dev team released a jb for the iPhone 4.. I don't know if I'll want it..

[Red Bread]

Yep, little more lag, but the threading emails is handy and saves me from going directly to the gmail page. I'm in the second round of deliveries for the 4g, so not too worried about it.

[BTM]

My jailbroken 3GS runs nearly as seemless as always, I'm running SBSettings, 5icon dock/columns, glasklart icons, backgrounder (I think those are the ones always running and that would have an effect on performance)

The only thing really affected is battery life but hell I knew the battery wasn't very good before I bought it, so not very surprising. Also sometimes when charging the phone gets very hot, but I've heard of this in non JB phones as well so not sure what to make of it.

Overall still happy with, can't wait till my sister gets her 4 so I can compare

[Armada]

I've been on it for a few months. It's nothing special. Most stable OS I've ran on the iPhone though so I love that. Now that devs are incorporating the new APIs you can start enjoying the new features.

[len56]

it actually made the homescreen on my 3g smoother (going between pages etc. has a better frame rate) but yeah the menus are laggy :/

[oct1285]

like everyone else is saying menus and windows are kind of laggy on my 3gs. But I do enjoy being able to play pandora and use safari at the same time. Hopefully apple puts out an update and fixes the lag.

[X1 Trojan]

you guys are comparing apples to oranges.

you cant compare jb to oem

[ZJP]

anyone else having problems updating to iOS4 in iTunes? I keep getting a message that says:

"The iPhone software update server could not be contacted."

[Minefield]

Very laggy but battery life seems to have increased.

[Memphis1]

i got it just for two day interim before i get the iphone 4, but it has no lag on my 3gs and i did notice a better battery life today. the folders are really nice, the multi tasking is nice too, and maybe i'm just going crazy or something, but i could've sworn the phone calls were clearer.

[BTM]

Originally Posted by 335 Trojan

you guys are comparing apples to oranges.

you cant compare jb to oem

I don't think it's that drastic to compare what a phone comes like from Apple to what it is capable of doing...people are interested in what their phones are capable of, and iOS4 seems in many ways to be an attempt to level the iphones capabilities with competitors and with JB iphones, so why not compare the two? They are both free upgrades

[X1 Trojan]

Originally Posted by BTM

I don't think it's that drastic to compare what a phone comes like from Apple to what it is capable of doing...people are interested in what their phones are capable of, and iOS4 seems in many ways to be an attempt to level the iphones capabilities with competitors and with JB iphones, so why not compare the two? They are both free upgrades

i guess thats a good point. it just seems like comparing a new software update from BMW to JB3 or something. just different things

[E90SLAM]

works smoother on my 3Gs

[AW335TT]

I dont think apple is trying to beat any competitor, im sure apple is well aware of its fan base and is basicaly giving people just enough to have them buy it. Do you guys honestly think if apple wanted they couldn't put anything and everything into the iphone? Look at the Ipad, if microsoft made something with such limited capabilites it wouldn't be nearly as successful. Ever since apple came out with the first Ipod, ppl basicaly buy anything they make, and all competitors know that which is why if they even want to compete they have to offer a lottt more.

With that being said.. IPhone 4 arrives tomorrowww..

[radiantm3]

Originally Posted by AW335TT

I dont think apple is trying to beat any competitor, im sure apple is well aware of its fan base and is basicaly giving people just enough to have them buy it. Do you guys honestly think if apple wanted they couldn't put anything and everything into the iphone? Look at the Ipad, if microsoft made something with such limited capabilites it wouldn't be nearly as successful. Ever since apple came out with the first Ipod, ppl basicaly buy anything they make, and all competitors know that which is why if they even want to compete they have to offer a lottt more.

With that being said.. IPhone 4 arrives tomorrowww..

WRONG. Apple's philosophy has always been providing the best user experience. They don't compete with the competition on bullet points. They go for quality over quantity. They don't care if users want flash. They know why flash is bad for mobile platforms and make decisions that THEY believe is best for the platforms and their customers. Customers don't know what's better for the platform. But you are right in one area. If people keep buying Apple devices, then to them, they are doing something right. As long as they are successful, they will make decisions based on what they think is best.